Men & Connection / Relationships
You’re Trying to Do Everything Right, but Your Partner Still Feels Alone
What happens when the work you do to show love and the closeness your partner misses are two different conversations.
By Maxwell Ziegenhagen
By the time your partner tells you they feel alone, you’ve been trying all day to make sure they don’t have to do everything alone.
You picked up the kids. You remembered the thing they asked you to get on your way home. You could tell they were tired, so you handled dinner, including the part where someone who specifically asked for their sauce on the side was devastated to find their sauce on the side.
And then, after the kids are in bed, your partner says, “I feel like I barely saw you today.”
You’re standing at the sink. You can see the dishes from the dinner you made. You say, “I’ve been here all night.”
Which is true.
And now you’re having an argument neither of you can quite believe you’re having. You think you’re being told that what you did all day didn’t count. Your partner was trying to tell you they missed you.
The things you do are part of how you love
I think a lot of men hear a version of this complaint and immediately start doing math.
I picked up the kids three days this week. I’ve been getting up with the baby. I called your mom back. When you said you needed more help, I listened. I changed things. What are we even talking about right now?
There’s a reason you reach for the list. You want your partner to see that you’ve been thinking about them. When you filled up their car because they had to leave early, you were imagining them half awake at a gas station in the cold. When you took the kids out on Saturday morning, you knew they’d been trying to read the same chapter of the same book for three weeks. You were paying attention. You wanted their life to feel a little easier because you were in it.
So when they say they feel alone, it can land somewhere much deeper than the conversation you’re having at the sink. If you can’t feel that I love you, what have I been doing all this time?
I wish more couples could get to that question. Usually, by then, they’re arguing about whether taking the kids out on Saturday was something he did for her or something he was supposed to be doing anyway.
And sometimes that’s a real argument worth having. There’s a difference between making dinner because you noticed it needed making and making dinner after your partner chose the meal, checked the fridge, texted you the recipe, and answered three calls from the grocery store. They may be tired from carrying more than either of you has fully accounted for. They may also miss you. It’s possible to have both conversations if you can hear which one they’re trying to start.
The conversation you almost had
Imagine your partner tells you, while you’re getting dinner ready, that their sister called.
“She sounded like Mom used to when she wanted me to know she was mad without actually saying it.”
You know this family. You know how these calls go. So you say, “You can call her tomorrow. You don’t have to deal with it tonight.” Then you ask if they can get the kids to wash their hands.
Your advice may be exactly right. But there was a conversation inside that moment that neither of you got to have. Maybe your partner was about to tell you they went into the bathroom after the call and sat there for ten minutes because they suddenly felt fifteen again. Maybe they wanted to tell you how embarrassed they were that their sister could still do that to them. Maybe they hadn’t figured out why it bothered them and wanted to hear themselves say it to someone who knew the whole family.
By bedtime, what they remember is that they came close to telling you and then helped a six-year-old find his other sock.
These moments are easy to miss because they rarely come with an announcement. Your partner says, “My sister called.” You hear a piece of information and respond to it. They were seeing whether they could tell you what it was like to be them that afternoon.
And if you’re the guy at the sink, you’ve probably had your version of this, too. You say, “Work was a mess today,” and your partner says, “Oh no, what happened?” You say, “Nothing. Just the usual.” You might genuinely want them to ask again. You might also be relieved when they don’t, because you aren’t sure what you’d say if they did.
Now there are two people in the kitchen who would like to be known a little better, both making it very easy for the other person to move on.
When every conversation feels like a performance review
By the time a couple has had this fight a dozen times, even an ordinary question can feel loaded.
Your partner says, “Can we talk for a minute?” You hear the opening line of a conversation in which you’re going to find out that something you thought was going fine has been hurting them for months. You start searching your memory for what you did. While they’re telling you how they feel, you’re already building a timeline.
They can see you doing it. You get very still. Your answers get shorter. They say, “See, this is what I mean. I can’t talk to you.”
You were trying so hard to get through the conversation without making it worse that you became almost impossible to reach.
There’s a lonely part of this for the man who’s trying, too. Maybe he’s already changed real things. Maybe he used to leave the room when they fought and now he stays. Maybe staying takes everything he has, and his partner is looking across the room wondering why he seems so far away. Both people can be telling the truth about the same five minutes.
I think some men have spent so long trying to be a good partner that they’ve become careful about letting their partner see them in the act of trying. They hide how much a comment hurt. They hide how often they feel unsure of themselves. They say “I’m fine” because they’re pretty sure whatever they’re feeling will become one more thing their partner has to deal with.
If you do that for long enough, your partner can share a home with you and have to guess whether you’re sad, irritated, worried, or simply thinking about the weird noise your car made that morning. You know you’re trying to spare them. They’re on the other side of the room trying to figure out if you still want to be there.
Let them hear the part you usually keep to yourself
Say your partner tells you, “I feel like I barely saw you today.”
You could put the dish down and say, “When you said that, I immediately wanted to tell you everything I did today. I wanted you to know I was thinking about you. But I think you’re telling me you missed me. Did I get that right?”
They might say yes. They might say, “I miss you, and I’m still upset about what happened this morning.” They might sit down at the kitchen table and tell you about their sister.
There’s room for your day in that conversation, too. “I missed you. I was also hurt this morning, and I think I’ve been keeping busy because I didn’t know how to bring it up.” That sentence gives your partner something they can respond to. Up until then, all they could see was a man who seemed unusually invested in getting every dish into the dishwasher.
Sometimes you really do need ten minutes to finish what you’re doing and collect yourself. Say that. Then go find them when the ten minutes are up. There’s a kind of tenderness in your partner hearing your footsteps coming down the hall and realizing they don’t have to ask you a second time.
And please let some of this happen when things are good. Tell them the ridiculous thing you almost texted them at lunch. Ask if they want to sit outside with you for a few minutes after the kids go down. When something good happens and you find yourself looking for them across the room, go tell them. Give them a chance to feel how often they cross your mind.
I keep thinking about that man at the sink. He made dinner because he loves his partner. He stood there defending dinner because, for a minute, he thought it was his best evidence.
And maybe what he wanted to say, if he’d known how to say it, was something much simpler.
“I missed you today, too. Come sit with me for a minute.”
Learn about The ReConnect