Men & Connection / Friendship
The Quiet Loneliness of Men Who Have Friends
What two Saturdays reveal about men’s friendships, loneliness, and the ordinary time it takes to feel known.
By Maxwell Ziegenhagen · Adapted from Disconnected: The Quiet Crisis of Modern Men
At twenty-eight, he had a Saturday with nobody in it. At forty-eight, he had a house full of his closest friends and felt lonely the minute they left.
I think about these two men together because the first one could easily grow up to become the second.
The twenty-eight-year-old woke up around eight. He had a good job, a decent apartment, and a group chat that had been active most of the week. He got up, made coffee, looked at his phone, and considered going to the gym. There was no particular reason to go then, so he didn’t.
Eventually he got lunch somewhere. He ate it looking at his phone. He ran an errand he could have done Monday. When he finally went to the gym, he spent an hour in a room full of people and spoke to nobody.
At some point that afternoon he thought about texting a friend. Hey, what are you doing? An ordinary question, except he knew what he was really asking. Is there room for me in your day? He imagined his friend saying he was busy and decided he could probably find something else to watch.
If you’d asked how his Saturday went, he would have said, “Fine. Didn’t really do much.”
The forty-eight-year-old had recently moved. A few of his old friends came over to help. At first, they were almost formal about it. Is this going upstairs? Which room is yours? Then someone made a joke that belonged to twenty years ago. Someone else insisted that was absolutely not how it happened. Eventually, they were laughing hard enough that nobody was moving anything.
They ate pizza on the floor because the furniture was still in the wrong rooms. He could start a story halfway through and trust everyone to catch up. Somebody gave him shit about a thing he’d been doing since he was twenty, and he laughed because he’d forgotten anyone still remembered.
Then somebody checked the time. One had to get home to his kids. Another had a long drive. They hugged, said they should do this again soon, and left.
The pizza boxes were still on the floor when the house went quiet.
He told me it was one of the best days he’d had in a long time. I think the reason it hurt so much when they left was that he’d spent the afternoon remembering how easy it used to be to feel like himself around them. And now he had no idea when he’d see them again.
What he may be missing is Tuesday
Ask a man if he has friends and he might give you six names without thinking. Ask which of those men he expects to see next week and he might need to check whether anyone has a birthday coming up.
I keep coming back to Tuesday because there’s so little to recommend it. Nobody gets married on a Tuesday if they can help it. There’s no long weekend to plan around. It’s the night you go over to your friend’s house while he’s still getting his kids to bed. You stand in his kitchen and eat a handful of whatever’s on the counter. He comes downstairs, tells you something ridiculous his daughter said, and at some point you remember the reason you wanted to see him. Or you forget, and the evening is good anyway.
When you’re young, you get a surprising amount of this time for free. The same kid is at lunch tomorrow. You ride home with the same guys after practice. In college, a friend can knock on your door because he’s bored. Imagine announcing that as the reason for a visit at forty. You’d probably feel compelled to bring something.
The places we used to see people could be complicated. A small town might give you a dozen people who’d show up when you needed them and still make it hard to be honest about who you were. I’m glad we have more freedom to go somewhere else and find people we can be ourselves with. The trick is that once you find them, you still need a place to see them next Tuesday.
And there are plenty of good reasons to go home. There are kids to put to bed, early meetings, and people we love who’ve been waiting to see us all day. Your friend moves forty minutes away. The pickup game loses its gym. A standing dinner goes from every week to whenever everybody can make it. Six months later, the group chat is still going strong.
One thing I miss about spending ordinary time with people is that I get to know what happened before they figured out how to tell the story. I hear about the job they might quit while they still feel embarrassed to be thinking about quitting. I see how happy they are about something too small to call me about. They get to know those things about me, too.
When I see a friend twice a year, we can have a wonderful dinner. We can also spend most of it giving each other the version of our lives that fits between ordering and paying. I’ve driven home from dinners like that and remembered the thing I’d actually wanted to tell him.
How boys learn to say it sideways
A little boy can stand at the window and ask every three minutes when his friend is coming over. When the friend finally arrives, he runs to the door. When it’s time to go home, he asks if he can stay the night. Everyone in the house knows exactly how much the friendship means to him. He’s made it impossible to miss.
Somewhere along the way, plenty of boys get more careful. They still want their friend to come over. They’d just prefer to convey it in a way that leaves open the possibility that they couldn’t care less.
“Are you coming or what?”
There’s real tenderness in that sentence if you know the person saying it. The trouble comes when two men spend years giving each other just enough room to pretend they don’t mind. One assumes his friend has enough going on. The other figures he’d hear from him if he wanted to hang out. Both would have been genuinely happy to get the call.
I understand the impulse. Saying “I miss you” to a friend can feel oddly riskier than telling him something objectively more personal. I can tell you about my divorce or my terrible week and still keep the conversation mostly about me. If I tell you I miss you, I’ve said something about us. Now I have to sit there while you decide what to do with it.
And sometimes the answer is, “Yeah, man. Me too.” Then one of you makes fun of the other’s shoes and you both feel better.
What happens after the joke?
Some of the best conversations of my life have happened with a windshield in front of me. There’s something about a long drive that lets a man say what he’s thinking and give you both a mile or two to sit with it. A garage can do the same thing. So can a walk. And sometimes playing basketball with the same guys every Thursday is one of the best parts of your week because you get to play basketball with the same guys every Thursday. There’s a particular pleasure in somebody giving you a hard time for missing last week. He noticed.
I also know men who would happily skip the golf and go straight to the two-hour conversation afterward. They want to know how you felt when your dad called. They remember what you said about your marriage six months ago. Some of them have spent years in groups they genuinely enjoy, trying little ways of finding out if there’s room for the kind of closeness they want. They ask a more personal question. They mention that things at home have been hard. They let a serious moment go on a few seconds longer than usual.
Sometimes somebody meets them there. Sometimes somebody makes a joke and the conversation moves on.
I like the joke. Sometimes I’m the one making it. I also want friendships where, after we laugh, one of us can say, “Seriously, though. How are you doing with that?” And then wait long enough to hear the answer.
I think about the kinds of care men already know how to give. A man will get up before dawn to drive his friend to the airport. He’ll sit next to him at his father’s funeral and stay until the last folding chair gets put away. If he knows there’s something heavy to carry, he’ll come over and grab the other end.
Sometimes the hardest part is giving him a chance to find out there’s something heavy in the first place.
Give your friends a chance to know the person you are now
Old friends can remember the person you were so vividly that it feels like being handed back a piece of yourself. They can also be the people you’re most nervous to show how much you’ve changed.
Think about the friend who knew you when you were twenty. He might know you as the guy who could make any night fun, even the night somebody got dumped. If you’ve spent the last year feeling flat, you might still find yourself telling him a funny story about it. You know how to be that guy with him. He knows how to love that guy. There’s comfort in it, especially when so much else in your life feels unfamiliar.
There’s also a particular kind of relief in hearing somebody who’s known you that long say, “I didn’t know you felt that way. Tell me more.”
I want more opportunities for that to happen before somebody’s life falls apart. I want a friend to know I’m excited about something while I’m still a little sheepish about how much I want it. I want to know what he’s like with his kids when everybody’s tired and dinner is going badly. I want us to have enough time together that he can tell me the same story three times and I can give him shit the third time and still let him finish.
That kind of friendship takes up space. Some of it will look like an evening you could have used to get things done. You might have to invite a guy over while the house is a mess, or ask him to come along on a walk you were already taking. You might have to risk being the one who asks twice.
“I’m walking the dog Tuesday around seven. Want to come?”
And somewhere along the way, when he asks how you’ve been, give him one more sentence than you usually do. “Work’s good. I’ve been feeling a little off lately, actually.” Or tell him the good thing you’ve been waiting for someone to ask about. Give him a minute. He might have something he’s been waiting to say, too.
I keep thinking about those men eating pizza on the floor. At some point they finished moving everything, and then they stayed. They sat in a room that barely had furniture and told stories they’d heard before. When it was time to go, they said what most of us say. “We should do this again soon.”
I wonder what would have happened if one of them, halfway to his car, had turned around and said, “You home Tuesday?”
Explore the Friendship ReConnect guide